Compared to other works I've seen so far, this one is less in the realm of magical and suspense, equipped with much fewer whimsical and enchanting moments in the traditional sense...there is clear imbalance among these protagonists, with Ida being the one with (significantly) least screen time, but Rivette likely doesn't care. The eventual encounter of the other 2, Louise and Ninon, and the bonding thereafter, is clearly reminiscent of Celine and Julie Go Boating, and that includes their joint effort in subverting gender dynamics...see full review at https://letterboxd.com/ziggyzaggy/film/up-down-fragile/
#TIFF2022#4.5. In this seemingly unsettling, haunted hotel,Tilda Swinton化身为名为“母女”的二重身而对于Hogg而言motherhood可以symbolize as the so-called phantom, both internal and external.在特定空间里利用灵异元素讲述 melodrama已经有同为A24出品的the humans在前(也更为戏剧),而本片真正“永恒”的却是身处同一空间却有不同灵魂并互相对话的Swinton,在映后Q&A她回顾创作以及自己母亲与女儿的身份地下偶像sana未增删带翻译带来的感动甚至超越她任何影像的总和.She's everything.